ranchandsyrup

The best blog. Maybe in this whole town.

And he is not one of us. He has never been one of us.

It’s fallacy exploration time again and today we’re going to tackle the No True Scotsman (“NTS”) fallacy. Generally, it occurs when a member of a group attempts to disassociate herself from the actions of a fellow group member by claiming that the other group member wasn’t ever really a part of the group. Basically it means that a person re-defines the group to exclude the “undesirable” actor leaving themselves and their precious narrative free from consequences.

The most common usage of the NTS fallacy is a Republican deeming a fellow republican to be a “RINO”, Republican in name only. Another common usage is the saying, “Conservatism can’t fail, it can only be failed.” Here are some quotes from a serial abuser of the fallacy:

“Republicans lost last night but conservatism did not, and that is, to me, one of the fundamental elements of last night’s results. Conservatism did not lose; Republicans lost last night.” – Rush Limbaugh, 11/8/2006

“Conservatism did not lose last night. Conservative was not on the ballot.” – Rush Limbaugh, 11/5/2008

“Conservatism, in my humble opinion, did not lose last night. It’s just very difficult to beat Santa Claus.” – Rush Limbaugh, 11/7/2012

I use El Rushbo as an example because it is my belief that the epistemic closure of conservatives in general as enabled by their preferred media does not allow conservatives to honestly and objectively analyze or understand why conservative ideas sometimes fail. I understand the incentive for the conservative media to abuse this fallacy. They are invested in a narrative and gain financially by doing so. They do not have a duty to accurately inform you contra their narrative. The rank and file conservative has a different incentive. They just don’t want to believe what their lying eyes and ears are telling them. I get this as well. It’s not enjoyable to be wrong. However, the lazy NTS fallacy severely diminishes your ability to be “right” going forward (if that’s something you care about). Would you run your business or family this way? In my business if there is a mistake or outcome that we don’t like, we perform a root-cause analysis. We don’t make up plausible excuses that conform to our narrative and then quit investigating.

There is no ideology or belief that is correct or “right” every single time. People that have that sort of expectation or belief have to delude themselves to maintain their narrative. When you see people use the NTS fallacy, you should be (rightly) skeptical of their motives. They have crafted what they think is an unassailable position. They are just aping their media sources/heroes by painting themselves in a corner and lashing out/playing defense. That demonstrates someone arguing in bad faith and they should be roundly mocked. Why? Because it is very likely that they would have cheered the actions that they are decrying if they produced results that furthered their narrative.

About these ads

Single Post Navigation

One thought on “And he is not one of us. He has never been one of us.

  1. Nancy Eberle on said:

    Your last sentence says it all… Romney/Obamacare is a fine example… This glaring truth becomes evident ad nauseum. (This morning I overheard someone on CNN ask “Arnold for POTUS?” ummm… If I hear one birther push this notion, I swear, I will yoink the TV out of the wall and throw it out the back door.) If the USA is the greatest country in the world, why don’t we have: bullet trains, vertical hydroponic agriculture, alternative energy and advanced medicine available to all, fully implemented by now? We have the technology and the money. We know why. Because it will work and it will be good. What a disgrace. So many simple solutions on the table. So few outside interests blocking the way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

On the public record

Methodically insulting all my possible future employers.

Sever The City

In search of a life more liberated

LindyJordan

Lifestyle, adventure, fun

Schroedinger's Cat

Many worlds and one cat

So Many Feebs.

So little time.

Corey Robin

Author of The Reactionary Mind: Conservatism from Edmund Burke to Sarah Palin

My Ready Room

“The Tea Party is our Taliban.”

Emily L. Hauser - In My Head

Writer, social activist, a lot of Israel/Palestine, and general mental rambling

Southern Beale

Mad As Y'all, Not Taking It Anymore

Shannon A Thompson

You need the world, and the world needs good people.

The Inverse Square Blog

science and the public square -- by thomas levenson

125fuckingdegreesfahrenheit

The temperature at which your brain melts

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 595 other followers

%d bloggers like this: